This is a great little write-up. Good work.

These kinds of reviews are essential in my opinion. From reading this little review a user can understand the pros and cons of each module so they can make an informed decision on which is best for them without needing to download and test each module. A developer can easily see where the shortcomings are in each and therefore it becomes easier to develop a more flexible and usable module.

Maybe we should have a 'contributed modules comparison' section in the docs? It's quite similar to Comparison of "lightbox" type modules by snpower which is great. I really feel these are essential for new users and developers alike. I'm the developer of the shadowbox module and it's certainly spurring me on to get all those green ticks instead of red crosses!